Accession of Cyprus to the European Union may provide the catalyst to resolve the island’s dispute, December 2001

Author (Person)
Publisher
Series Title
Series Details 7.12.01
Publication Date 07/12/2001
Content Type , ,

Background and reporting on the week's main stories in the European Union and the wider Europe

The prospect of Cyprus soon becoming a member of the European Union may have provided the catalyst needed to solve the 27-year long division of the island, following successful talks between Clacfos Clerides, the Greek Cypriot President and his Turkish Cypriot counterpart, Rauf Denktash, on Tuesday 4 December 2001.

The two leaders, meeting at their first direct talks for more than four years in the United Nations patrolled buffer zone on the island, agreed to meet again in January 2002 to begin negotiations which would not end until an agreement was reached on the future of the long-divided island.

While the EU would prefer for a solution to the problem to be reached before enlargement, Günter Verheugen, the European Commissioner for Enlargement, pointed out in a statement, following Denktash's refusal to attend UN talks on 12 September 2001, that a solution 'is not a pre-condition for Cyprus's accession'. According to the latest Regular Report [SEC(2001)1745)] on Cyprus' progress towards accession, published in November 2001, Cyprus is among the ten candidate countries which should be able to conclude negotiations by the end of 2002 and therefore join the EU ahead of the European Parliament elections in 2004.

Background

  • The Cyprus Dispute

The current division of the island dates back to 20 July 1974 when Turkish troops invaded the Republic of Cyprus in response to the coup d'etat on 15 July 1974 against the legal Cyprus government by the military junta ruling Greece at the time. The international community strongly condemned the military invasion and rejected Turkey's explanations.

However, Turkey ignored the international community and launched a second offensive in August 1974 seizing more than one third of the territory of the Republic of Cyprus in the northern part of the island where 70 per cent of the island's natural resources are located. This led to the displacement of some 200,000 Greek Cypriots from the northern part of the island where they had constituted 80 per cent of the inhabitants. The Turkish-Cypriots went on to declare the occupied area as an independent state in 1983 known as the 'Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus'. The move was condemned by the international community and the UN Security Council in its Resolution 541 of 1983. In fact the state has only ever been recognised by Turkey and is totally dependent on it.

Three decades later, 35,000 Turkish soldiers are still stationed in the occupied area, making it, according to the UN Secretary General one of the most militarised regions in the world. Moreover, some 110,000 Turkish settlers have been brought over from Turkey to colonise the occupied area, in an attempt to change the demographic character of the island. These settlers, while Turks, are completely different culturally from the Turkish-Cypriots whose culture is very similar to their Greek counterparts. The Turkish-Cypriots are thus becoming a minority in the occupied areas and are migrating to other western countries - Turkish-Cypriot newspapers suggest that about 50,000 Turkish Cypriots emigrated from the occupied area in the three decades following the invasion because of the poor economic and social conditions there. This means that the Turkish Cypriots themselves are now outnumbered by the Turkish troops and colonists.

There are several web sites which provide detailed information on the history and background of the Cyprus dispute. Of these, the Permanent Mission of Cyprus to the United Nations web page on The Cyprus Issue and the UN 1976 Paper on the Cyprus Problem offers one of the best overviews of the dispute. The Cyprus Problem web site covers the issue in depth with several notable sections on the results of the Turkish invasion including pages on:

  • Finding A Solution

The United Nations has been trying to broker a peace deal ever since the 1974 invasion. In 1997, it successfully got the two sides to agree on the basis for a reconciliation which has since been seen as the point from which all negotiations must start. The agreement sets out the following four key principles:

  • an independent, non-aligned, bi-communal Federal Republic
  • territory under the administration of each community should be discussed in the light of economic viability
  • questions of principles like freedom of movement, freedom of settlement, the right of property and other specific matters, are open for discussion taking into consideration the fundamental basis of a bi-communal federal system and certain difficulties which may arise for the Turkish Cypriot community.
  • the powers and functions of the central federal government will be such as to safeguard the unity of the country having regard to the bi-communal character of the state.

However, both sides have consistently interpreted the principles differently, especially the latter two, and this has repeatedly led to the breakdown in negotiations just when it seems as though the United Nations efforts may be about to find a solution.

The UN efforts of the 1980s and 1990s are covered in detail on the Cyprus Problem's page entitled 'Detailed History' while the European Union's latest Regular Report on Cyprus also covers the UN's attempts to find a political settlement to the dispute during 2000 and up until June 2001.

However, the UN-sponsored peace talks held on 4 December 2001 appear more promising with both sides agreeing to meet in January 2002 to start negotiations which will not end until an agreement is reached. Moreover, Alvara de Soto, Special Adviser to the UN Secretary- General has said the two leaders are determined to reach a settlement in six months. Indeed, the day after the meeting President Clerides made a historic trip to the Turkish occupied part of the island to join Rauf Denktash for dinner, becoming the first Greek-Cypriot President to cross the United Nations so called 'Green Line' into the occupied area since its partition 27 years ago. The UN is proposing for Cyprus to become a bi-zonal federation with a joint Greek Cypriot/ Turkish Cypriot Government in the capital Nicosia.

The latest progress after years of deadlock is widely seen as a response to Cyprus' planned accession to the European Union.

  • Cyprus and EU Enlargement

Cyprus' relationship with the European Union dates back to the Association Agreement in 1972 and the relationship has evolved steadily ever since. In 1987, a Customs Union Protocol was signed, followed by the application for full membership in 1990. This application received the positive Opinion of the European Commission in 1993, which concluded that the application was made in the name of the whole island. Indeed, when accession negotiations began in March 1998 Turkish Cypriots were invited to be included in the Cypriot delegation and since the substantive negotiations for the adoption and the implementation of the EU legislation began in November 1998 a reference to the Turkish Cypriot community has been included in every position paper.

To trace the development of the EU approach to the accession of Cyprus to the European Union you can use these services.

  • OEIL (Legislative Observatory) (provides a full history of the proposal with summaries of each major stage in the process)
  • Pre-Lex (provides a full and concise calendar of the proposal, bibliographical references and some hyperlinks to full text sources)

Cyprus is now considered to be one of the frontrunners in the candidate countries for accession to the European Union. By July 2001 it had concluded negotiations on 23 of the 29 chapters (a further two chapters 'institutions' and ' other' are noted but not negotiated). For more details on the chapters negotiated consult the Cyprus and EU accession negotiations website's page on chapters under negotiation. According to the latest Regular Reports on Enlargement published in November 2001 Cyprus has met the political criteria for the rule of law, human rights and an independent judiciary. The Cypriot economy is also flourishing as a result of tourism and services and according to the European Commission 'should be able to cope with competitive pressure and market forces in the Union'. Indeed the Greek-Cypriot per capita income, at 82 per cent of the EU average, is already higher than two of the EU's current members: Greece and Portugal. There are still negotiations to be concluded on agriculture but as this accounts for only 4 per cent of the nation's gross domestic product the European Commission does not foresee any problems. A tax reform that would effectively reduce the corporate tax burden to less than 20 per cent has also been proposed by the centre-right government, in the hope that this would encourage international companies to have Cyprus as their EU base. All these factors have put Cyprus on the list of countries to join in 2004, irrespective of a settlement of the island dispute.

However, while the European Union is seeking to officially maintain that a solution to the island dispute is not an issue, it is clearly likely to cause tensions if it remains unresolved. The Dutch parliament has already passed a resolution saying that the EU should not admit a divided Cyprus while Greece has threatened to veto further enlargement if Cyprus' accession is blocked. Between the two extremes lies France, which some Central and Eastern European countries fear may use the Cyprus issue to block an enlargement which they are unsure about.

In this context, there is no surprise that the EU is putting pressure on the two sides to resolve the dispute and there is also the issue of the EU's relationship with Turkey. The Ankara government has threatened to annex the Northern Republic of Cyprus if the EU allows the Southern Republic to join ahead of a solution being found. Even if a solution is found, Rauf Denktash has said that he does not want the Northern Republic to become an EU member ahead of Turkey which still has to make considerable political reforms and human rights improvements and will certainly not be in the first wave of new members.

With all these factors, the road of Cyprus to the European Union is certainly a bumpy one and while the agreement to launch a new round of negotiations to solve the island dispute in January 2002 may have cleared a high hurdle, several obstacles remain. Not least, the actual ability of the two sides to find a solution on which they can both agree is yet to be seen.

Further information within European Sources Online:

European Sources Online: Topic Guides
Information on European countries: Republic of Cyprus [Kypriaki Dimokratia]
Information on European countries: Greece
Information on European countries: Turkey
Enlargement of the European Union
European Sources Online: In Focus
European Commission adopts 'Enlargement strategy paper', 'Regular Reports' for each of the applicant countries and an 'Accession Partnership' for Turkey, November 2000
Progress on enlargement, November 2001, November 2001
 
European Sources Online: European Voice:
11.06.98 Cyprus question leaves Union between rock and a hard place
05.11.98 Dispute over Cyprus threatens to overshadow enlargement talks
09.03.00 Turkish Cypriots urged to join entry talks
23.11.00 Ecevit delivers stark warning over Cyprus
18.01.01 Commissioner Günter Verheugen expressed concern at an apparent hardening of Turkey's attitude over Cyprus
03.05.01 Turkish Cypriots warn Union: don't accept a divided country
24.05.01 Cyprus rides the crest of enlargement's first wave
25.10.01 Turkish Cypriot leader snubbed
 
European Sources Online: Financial Times
19.07.01 Divided Cyprus threatens to veto expansion of EU
20.07.01 Troubles of a divided island
06.09.01 Cyprus talks too soon, says Denktash
05.11.01 Annexation threat by Turkey if EU admits Cyprus
10.11.01 Denktash invites Clerides to talks
13.11.01 Ten nations on track to join EU
15.11.01 EU throws down the Cyprus gauntlet as it pursues policy on enlargement
19.11.01 Leaders to hold Cyprus talks
27.11.01 Goal of joining EU fails to reunite island
30.11.01 Old friends pressed to settle old enmities: Cyprus's division has been brought to the fore by plans for the island to enter the EU
05.12.01 Cyprus leaders agree to hold face to face talks
 

Further information can be seen in these external links:

  • European Union Institutions
European Commission: DG Press and Communication Service
Press Releases:
    22.08.97 Commissioner van de Broek concerned about lack of progress on Cyprus issue (IP/97/763)
    17.12.97 Vocational Training: Leonardo da Vinci welcomes the first Czech and Cypriot projects (IP/97/1175)
    25.03.98 Accession Partnerships will guide applicants towards EU membership (IP/98/274)
    04.11.98 Commission adopts reports on progress by candidate countries (IP/98/964)
    22.03.00 Commissioner Günter Verheugen in Cyprus to support UN proximity talks and to praise the country's progress towards enlargement (IP/00/285)
    05.06.01 Commission to negotiate agreements with Cyprus, Malta and Turkey for participation in EU programmes (IP/01/777)
    06.09.01 Statement by Enlargement Commissioner Günter Verheugen on Cyprus (IP/01/1245)
    06.12.01 Diamantopoulou welcomes Cyprus's agreement to shadow Community employment policy in the run-up to accession
    07.12.01 Cyprus: Diamantopoulou plans to bring together Greek and Turkish communities on EU policies for social dialogue, the disabled and equal opportunities.(IP/01/1771)
Speeches
    25.09.01 Romano Prodi: President of the European Commission Speech to the House of Representatives Cyprus (SPEECH/01/495)
    02.12.97 Hans van den Broek: Bi-communal co-operation: the path to mutual trust and reconciliation (SPEECH/97/272)
Memos
    28.11.97 Relations EU/Cyprus (MEMO/97/103)

Further and subsequent Press Releases and related sources from the European Commission relating to Cyprus can be found by inserting 'CYP' in the 'Keywords' field on RAPID

European Commission: DG Enlargement

European Commission: DG External Relations

Council of the European Union: Newsroom
 
Press Releases:
    15.05.01 19th meeting of the Association Council between the European Union and Cyprus (PRES/01/187)
    23.10.01 Declaration by the Presidency on behalf of the European Union on Cyprus - United Nations process (PESC/01/166)

To trace adopted or proposed EU legislation which has explicit reference to Cyprus prior to its full future membership you can use either PreLex or the Legislative Observatory and insert 'Cyprus' as the subject in the 'words in title' field.

  • National Organisations

The Republic of Cyprus: Government

Permanent Mission of Cyprus to the United Nations

Greece: Ministry of Foreign Affairs

Turkish Republic of Cyprus: President's office

Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus: Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Defence: Public Relations Department:

Republic of Turkey: Ministry of Foreign Affairs

  • International Organisations

United Nations

  • Non-governmental Organisations

Peace-Cyprus.org

Hellenic Resources Network

Cyprus Problem

  • News Organisations

FT.com

01.12.01 Annan calls for more time
04.12.01 Cypriot talks may be key to EU enlargement
06.12.01 Hope in Cyprus

BBC News Online

27.11.00 Greece denounced Turkish-Cypriot leader's boycott
04.12.00 UN resumes Cyprus efforts
04.12.00 Denktash shuns UN talks on Cyprus
07.12.00 Turkish Cypriot leader warns UN
10.05.01 Turkey guilty of human rights abuse
11.05.01 Ecevit criticises rights ruling on Cyprus
24.05.01 Northern Cyprus coalition collapses
25.05.01 Turkish Cypriot prime minister resigns
27.05.01 Greek-Cypriots go to polls
14.06.01 The candidate countries
28.08.01 UN chief meets Turkish Cypriot leader
05.09.01 Turkish Cypriot leader shuns UN initiative
09.11.01 Turkish Cypriot leader pushes for meeting
23.11.01 Turkey holds key Cyprus debate
24.11.01 Turkey rejects Cyprus peace talks
03.12.01 Cyprus' quiet crisis
04.12.01 Cyprus leaders agree to pursue talks
05.12.01 Cyprus leaders hold historic meeting
05.12.01 Islanders welcome Cyprus agreement
06.12.01 Denktash warning on Cyprus optimism
Country profile:  Cyprus
Timeline:  Cyprus
Timeline:  Greece
Timeline:  Turkey

(long-term access cannot be guaranteed)

Further and subsequent information on the subject of this In Focus can be found by an 'Advanced Search' in European Sources Online by inserting 'Cyprus' in the keyword field.

Helen Bower,
Compiled: 7 December 2001

Talks between the Greek Cypriot leader and Turkish Cypriot leader took place on 4 December 2001 in an effort to end the 27 year long division of Cyprus before it joins the European Union in 2004.

Countries / Regions