Greenlanders come of age outside the Union

Date: 19/01/06

It is 21 years since Greenland, the only territory ever to vote to withdraw from the EU, ceased to be part of the Union. Officially a region of Denmark (but with extensive powers of self-government), a hard-fought referendum in November 1983 resulted in a 52%-48% decision to pull out.

Since January 1985, relations with the EU have been regulated by an agreement reached between the governments of Greenland and Denmark and the EU. The island, whose area is substantially greater than that of Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Spain combined, but whose population is a mere 56,000 (mostly Inuit), lost the right to receive help from the EU structural funds. But Greenland has continued to receive aid approximately equal to what it was getting before. Last year, the EU contributed around 7% of Greenland's budget (or around 40 million euro), while Denmark provided another 60%.

The main source of EU finance has been a fisheries agreement, which runs out at the end of this year, paying out money for the right of EU vessels to fish in Greenland's waters and for restructuring the fishing fleet. The European Court of Auditors recently criticised this arrangement, saying the Union was paying far too much for the minimal amount of fish caught.

The court's criticisms were backed up by the European Parliament. The European Commission resolved to seek a new basis for the Union's relations with the Danish dependency. Late last year it set up a taskforce, under the senior Luxembourg official Etienne Reuter, who had previously represented the EU in Hong Kong and Japan, to thrash out new proposals.

This could be a good time to re-open the question with the Greenlanders. Ever since 1983 its government has been dominated by the left-wing Siumit party, which had led the campaign for withdrawal. In elections last November, the governing coalition lost ground and though Hans Enoksen, the Siumit leader, remains prime minister, the centre-right Atassut party, which was pro-EU, has joined the government.

It is unlikely that the Greenlanders will want to re-run the referendum, at least in the immediate future, but they may now be more open to a new, and possibly closer, relationship with the Union. At the very least, they will want to ensure that a firmer basis is reached for the payment of EU money.

Reuter spelled out what was in it for the EU. It was not a matter of charity, he explained, but it was in the EU's self-interest to re-shape its relations with its northern neighbour. There were several fields in which the EU, as well as Greenland, could benefit from closer co-operation.

One of these was geo-strategic. Greenland provided part of the 'missile shield' for Western Europe, through the Thule radar base (the largest in the world), leased to the US, and staffed by Americans and Danes. The EU Galileo satellite system might well be able to use Thule.

Then there was the EU's interest in managing North Atlantic fishing in an ecological way. Greenland constituted an excellent laboratory for scientific research in climate change.

Greenland also had an excellent potential for the development of energy sources, including hydro-electricity, while under the ice cap and the Arctic Sea there may well be extensive mineral resources, as yet untouched.

The task force, which will report directly to the Commission's secretary-general and is working closely with around a dozen different directorates-general, is likely to take several months at least before coming up with a draft proposal. This is unlikely to take the form of a treaty, which would require ratification by all the member states.

It would, however, clearly have to be acceptable to the Danish government, which will find itself on both sides of the negotiating table, when talks start with the Greenlandic authorities, who do not enjoy sovereignty.

This is much to the chagrin of many Greenlanders, who are (at least in theory) in favour of independence, though they are only too aware of their financial dependence on the Danes.

Copenhagen has granted a large measure of autonomy to Greenland's government and parliament, based at Nuuk (formerly Godthab), a town of 13,000 inhabitants on the south-west coast. It has, however, retained control of monetary affairs, foreign and defence policy and justice and immigration.

The road to reaching an agreement may not be too smooth, but it is obviously in the interest of both sides to set the relationship on a new and firmer footing.

• Dick Leonard is a former assistant editor of The Economist.

Analysis feature on the EU's relations with Greenland anticipating negotiations on the renewal of the fisheries agreement, to expire at the end of 2006.

• Primary Source

European Commission: DG Development: OCTs: Greenland http://ec.europa.eu/fisheries/cfp/international/agreements/greenland/index_en.htm

---